Alien: Earth’s The Fly marks a stumble for Noah Hawley’s usually sharp brand of science fiction. The episode delivers some memorably gruesome alien sequences. However, the human characters’ baffling decisions undercut the tension, leaving what could have been a thrilling chapter feeling uneven and frustrating.
The Fly Overview
The Fly begins with momentum but loses its edge when the characters’ baffling choices undercut what could have been one of the series’ strongest and most gruesome installments.
The episode splits its focus: Boy Kavaliar meets with the Weyland-Yutani CEO in a tense settlement over damages from the crash. At the same time, in Neverland, Wendy struggles for autonomy against both her brother and Dame Sylvia. Meanwhile, Slightly sets Morrow’s plan into motion, unleashing the alien specimens on unsuspecting humans.
Sydney Chandler continues to elevate Wendy, who emerges with new confidence after her unsettling connection with the alien. No longer passive, she disagrees with her brother’s interpretation of her new lifestyle and Dame Sylvia’s handling of Nibs. Timothy Olyphant, as always, makes every scene count. Kirsh’s cutting “onion” line to Hermit (“That’s like an onion asking, ‘How do I take care of a star?’”) lands as one of the show’s sharpest moments.
Related Post
The settlement conference stands out as the episode’s high point: Kavaliar appears to outmaneuver Yutani, only for devastation to erupt on his own turf. However, momentum falters as Sylvia, Hermit, and Arthur make a string of implausible choices. Instead of playing as hubris, their actions feel like lapses in logic, pulling the episode away from its thematic weight.
Still, the climax delivers a bloody punch, salvaging tension even as the intelligence slips away. The Fly is the weakest episode of the season, but it leaves behind some of the season’s most memorable performances and imagery.
Alien: Earth is streaming on FX by Hulu.
Prodigy vs Weyland Yutani
The settlement scene crackles with tension. Boy Kavalier, barefoot and swaggering, strolls in and throws his feet on the table, signaling from the outset that he won’t play by corporate formality. The meeting, mediated by a representative of the Five Companies, quickly becomes a clash of wills.
Kavalier demands restitution for the crash. Yutani counters with her own request: the immediate return of the Maginot specimens. Kavalier pushes back, insisting on a six-week off-world quarantine before handing them over. When Yutani resists, he raises the stakes, threatening to take the conflict public. Forced to protect her company’s image, Yutani appears to relent.
On paper, Kavalier walks away the victor. But the triumph is hollow. Even as the settlement is inked, Yutani quietly authorizes Morrow to sidestep the agreement and secure the specimens immediately. With the help of Slightly and the reckless choices of supposed adults, Morrow sets his plan into motion, unraveling Kavalier’s apparent win before it can take hold.
Human Folly in Neverland
Three adult characters make baffling decisions in The Fly. Each one undercuts the episode’s momentum.
Hermit’s misstep is the most understandable. He can’t accept how much Wendy has changed, clinging to the fantasy of taking her home as if she were still his little sister. Kirsh cuts him down with brutal clarity. Wendy isn’t the girl he remembers; she’s something far more extraordinary, one of the most unique beings on the planet with a destiny far beyond family reunion. Still, Hermit’s protectiveness blinds him. He ropes Arthur into helping her escape.
Arthur’s own downfall stems from that choice. While resetting security protocols to clear a path, he notices one of the hybrids is offline. Slightly seizes the moment, lures him into the lab, and locks him inside. There, Arthur suffers the inevitable fate of a facehugger attack—an end that feels more like careless plotting than meaningful consequence.
Dame Sylvia fares no better. Shaken by Nibs’ attack in therapy, in episode four, she rashly decides to erase his memory back to before the crash. Even worse, she allows Nibs and Wendy to reconnect immediately after, as though the reset would go unnoticed. Wendy quickly pieces it together and confronts her, making it clear she refuses to be shaped by other people’s definitions of who she should be.
Each of these blunders could have been compelling if they felt like genuine expressions of human weakness or hubris. Instead, they come across as lapses in logic designed to move the plot forward, leaving the drama feeling manufactured rather than earned.
The Fly Final Thoughts
Alien: Earth’s The Fly ultimately illustrates the razor-thin line between bold storytelling and frustrating contrivance. The episode has all the ingredients of a standout entry. Yet its promise is undercut by a series of character decisions that strain believability. Rather than serving as tragic flaws or expressions of human hubris, these choices read as shortcuts, undermining the episode’s dramatic weight.
The Fly is not without its rewards. Chandler continues to bring depth and strength to Wendy, transforming her from a passive figure into a young woman asserting agency against both familial bonds and institutional authority. Olyphant also leaves his mark with a sharp, sardonic delivery that cuts through the murkier stretches of plotting. The settlement sequence is as gripping as anything Hawley has staged in the series so far, a reminder of the corporate duplicity at the heart of the Alien franchise.
The bloody climax, while brutal, restores some of the dread that seemed in danger of slipping away, ensuring the episode ends on a visceral note. Still, The Fly stands as the weakest installment of the season, a cautionary reminder of how quickly momentum can dissipate when logic falters. It’s a stumble, but one that still leaves behind striking performances and indelible imagery, proof that even a misstep in Alien: Earth can be memorable in its own right.
Alien: Earth - The Fly
-
Above Average - 6/106/10
