Peacemaker Season 2 Review: John Cena’s Terrific Performance Carries Uneven Season Premiere

Peacemaker Season 2 stumbles out of the gate, but strong performances from John Cena and Jennifer Holland, paired with a powerful emotional finale, set the stage for a season with promise.

Peacemaker Season 2 Overview

The Season 2 premiere of Peacemaker, written and directed by James Gunn, thrives when it explores the emotional weight carried by its characters. Christopher Smith/Peacemaker (John Cena), Emilia Harcourt (Jennifer Holland), Leota Adebayo (Danielle Brooks), John Economos (Steve Agee), and Adrian Chase/Vigilante (Freddie Stroma) all return from last season’s finale, but each finds themselves at a low point.

Smith’s dream of joining the Justice League has collapsed, Harcourt and Adebayo struggle to find meaningful work after Amanda Waller blacklists the team, and Economos barely clings to purpose under Rick Flagg Sr. (Frank Grillo). The result is a group fractured by failure, rejection, and disillusionment.

The premiere’s best material comes from watching Smith and Harcourt wrestle with that rejection. Harcourt numbs her pain by lashing out, picking fights that leave her battered. Smith, meanwhile, drowns himself in distraction, though one unnecessary and overlong orgy sequence undercuts what could have been a more resonant arc. Once Smith enters an alternate dimension, however, his story shifts into more compelling territory.

Cena continues to prove why he is perfect for the role, bringing depth to Peacemaker’s bravado. Some late-episode choices showcase his strongest acting yet in the series. Holland’s Harcourt also shines, with her physical and emotional unraveling giving the episode its rawest energy. Unfortunately, Adebayo feels sidelined, and all of the humor lands flat.

The premiere also stumbles in other areas. Tying the show into the “Superman 2025” universe feels forced, the Justice Gang cameo is painful, and the new opening song misses the mark entirely. Combined with the uneven humor, these choices create a rocky viewing experience.

Still, when Gunn narrows the focus to Smith and Harcourt’s fractured states of mind, the show regains its spark. The final act, with Smith’s emotional reckoning in another dimension, elevates the premiere to a level closer to Season 1’s highs. Imperfect but intriguing, Peacemaker Season 2 starts rough but hints at deeper, more rewarding storytelling ahead.

Peacemaker is streaming on HBO Max.

Rejection in Peacemaker Season 2

Rejection defines the Peacemaker Season 2 premiere, weighing heavily on each returning character. For Peacemaker, being shut out of the Justice League leaves him unmoored. Instead of facing that loss, he numbs himself with empty distractions. The orgy sequence, meant to symbolize his spiral, adds shock value. However, undercuts what could have been a more powerful exploration of his emptiness. Thankfully, once the story shifts to his alternate-dimension journey, the rejection driving him forward becomes more affecting.

Harcourt’s response to rejection is more visceral. Blacklisted and directionless, she throws herself into fights, welcoming physical pain as a way to mask her emotional turmoil. Jennifer Holland gives the episode’s standout performance. She grounds Harcourt’s violence in vulnerability and making her arc the most compelling of the premiere.

Economos and Adebayo embody rejection in quieter ways. Economos clings to relevance by working for Rick Flagg Sr. Adebayo is left sidelined, her reduced presence reflecting a growing sense of isolation.

The saving grace for these characters is that, despite rejection, they still have each other. Adebayo gives Peacemaker a ride to his interview. When he inevitably bombs it, Harcourt checks in on him in her own surly, guarded way. Economos, torn between protecting his new job and his loyalty to the team, convinces Adebayo to help out of concern for Peacemaker. These small acts of support highlight that even at their lowest, the team hasn’t stopped trying and that persistence gives the episode its heart.

Together, these threads create a throughline of characters defined not by their victories but by their inability to move past failure. The humor may falter and some story choices miss the mark, but the show’s willingness to confront how rejection reshapes its heroes gives the premiere emotional weight.

New Dimension

The episode takes a dramatic turn once Peacemaker steps through the portal into an alternate universe. There, he’s stunned to find his father, Auggie (Robert Patrick), and brother, Keith (David Denman, spot-on casting), alive and well, despite both being dead in his reality.

The quiet reunion between the three is the episode’s emotional high point. Cena delivers one of his best performances in the series, saying almost nothing yet communicating everything through body language and stunned silence. In this universe, the Smith family is celebrated as superheroes, a vision of what might have been. After a warm goodnight, Peacemaker wanders through his counterpart’s room, reflecting on the life he never had. This is everything Christopher always wanted.

That moment of peace is short-lived. The alternate-universe Peacemaker returns and attacks, forcing our Peacemaker into a desperate escape. The fight is brutal and one-sided, with the doppelgänger overpowering him at every turn. In the chaos, our Peacemaker accidentally kills his counterpart.

The episode closes on a haunting image: Peacemaker cradling the lifeless body of his other self. It’s a poignant end that reframes his journey.

Peacemaker Season 2 Final Thoughts

The Peacemaker Season 2 premiere is imperfect but promising. The episode stumbles out of the gate with tired humor and a distracting orgy sequence. However, the emotional core remains strong. James Gunn excels when focusing on the characters’ fractured states of mind. Cena delivers one of his finest performances in the series, conveying shock, grief, and introspection. Holland grounds Harcourt’s physical and emotional struggles in vulnerability, making her arc the premiere’s standout.

The episode’s exploration of rejection through Peacemaker’s failed Justice League ambitions, Harcourt’s self-destructive fighting, and the sidelining of Economos and Adebayo gives the story weight. Even in their lowest moments, the team’s small acts of support for each other provide heart and hope.

The finale, which sends Peacemaker into an alternate universe to meet a version of his family, elevates the episode. The happy moments with his father and brother, paired with the accidental death of his alternate self, set up Peacemaker’s season 2 journey.

Despite its missteps, the premiere hints at a season that could surpass its rocky start, blending dark humor, emotional depth, and high-stakes action. Peacemaker Season 2 may start unevenly, but it sets the stage for a compelling exploration of identity, failure, and the bonds that hold this team together.

Liked it? Take a second to support Chris Lee on Patreon!